Beneficiary Account with No Designation Sparks Litigation
June 3, 2026
Cats have nine lives, and Superman is impervious to everything but Kryptonite. The “pay on death” (POD) beneficiary designation beats them both on the durability scale.
Gift planners are aware of the need to encourage potential testators to identify, update and disclose (to someone) information about beneficiaries of bank accounts, insurance policies, 401(k) holdings and the like. The recent Colorado case of Estate of Arnold, 553 P.3d 264 (Col.App. 2024) presents a unique set of facts and a ruling that is jarring but expected.
A long time ago, decedent Michael Arnold was in a romantic relationship with Annette English. During their time together, Arnold opened a bank account and listed English as the sole beneficiary. Ten years or more before his death (the published decision is short on previse dates), the couple ended the relationship and marked its severance with a full-on settlement agreement which required Arnold to pay English $25,000 and English to release Arnold from “claims…of any nature” that were “related to their past relationship.” The agreement goes on to include a good deal more legalese clearly intended to wrap up anything and everything.
However, Arnold never removed English as the beneficiary of his POD bank account. A decade later he died. His will named his sister Lynn Arnold as executor and primary beneficiary. Lynn Arnold attempted to gain control of the bank account (now worth $165,000) as a probate asset. Her logic was that the settlement agreement effectively extinguished English’s interest, leaving the account with no named beneficiary. English saw it differently. The bank rightly left the matter to the court to decide.
The court awarded the account to English, stating that her entitlement was not a “claim” that she had waived in the agreement. It was simply a right that Arnold could have canceled but did not. His failure to act left the account status quo.
(This article was originally published on our LinkedIn on July 24, 2025.)